Carlls River fishing

Fishing at Carlls River has Brown Trout and Rainbow Trout on the stocking report. It is stocked about 7.2 times a year since 2011, most often in March and October. Species guides list dawn, day, and dusk for Brown Trout and dawn and dusk for Rainbow Trout.

Last stocked

March 1, 2025

Plants on record

108

Since 2011

Species recorded

Average size

10.1 in

Elevation

-1 ft

View larger map · Open on Google Maps

How Carlls River is stocked

The first plant of the year usually falls in the first week of March. In 2025 it was March 1, 2025, about when it usually is.

Argyle Lake (1 mi), Southards Pond (2 mi), Belmont Lake (3.7 mi), and Massapequa Lake (7.3 mi) were stocked more recently. Argyle Lake is also stocked with Brown Trout and Rainbow Trout, Southards Pond is also stocked with Brown Trout and Rainbow Trout, Belmont Lake is also stocked with Brown Trout and Rainbow Trout, and Massapequa Lake is also stocked with Brown Trout and Rainbow Trout.

Fish at Carlls River

Fishing Carlls River is most likely to be for Brown Trout. Brown Trout accounts for 73 of 108 plants on record, ahead of Rainbow Trout.

Brown Trout 73 plants

Plants: 73 of 108
Last stocked: March 1, 2025
Average length: 10.7 in

Seasons and rigs are on the Brown Trout guide.

Rainbow Trout 35 plants

Plants: 35 of 108
Last stocked: March 1, 2025
Average length: 8.9 in

Seasons and rigs are on the Rainbow Trout guide.

Fish stocked per year

8902011
9202012
8602013
8402014
9202015
9202016
8902017
8702018
9202019
7802020
9102021
9102022
9102023
9202024
9602025

Stocking history

Showing 15 of 108 plants Showing 108 plants

All species Brown Trout Rainbow Trout

Source: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
Date	Species	Quantity	Avg. length	Source
March 1, 2025	Brown Trout	40	13.6 in	report
March 1, 2025	Rainbow Trout	350	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2025	Brown Trout	510	7.1 in	report
March 1, 2025	Brown Trout	60	13.6 in	report
March 1, 2024	Rainbow Trout	330	8.2 in	report
March 1, 2024	Brown Trout	40	11.2 in	report
March 1, 2024	Brown Trout	60	11.2 in	report
March 1, 2024	Brown Trout	490	8.2 in	report
March 1, 2023	Brown Trout	40	13.7 in	report
March 1, 2023	Brown Trout	50	13.7 in	report
March 1, 2023	Brown Trout	490	9 in	report
March 1, 2023	Rainbow Trout	330	9.4 in	report
March 1, 2022	Rainbow Trout	330	9 in	report
March 1, 2022	Brown Trout	90	13.5 in	report
March 1, 2022	Brown Trout	490	9 in	report
March 1, 2021	Brown Trout	50	13.2 in	report
March 1, 2021	Brown Trout	40	13.2 in	report
March 1, 2021	Rainbow Trout	330	9.2 in	report
March 1, 2021	Brown Trout	490	8.8 in	report
November 1, 2020	Brown Trout	50	12.3 in	report
October 1, 2020	Brown Trout	100	12.6 in	report
May 1, 2020	Brown Trout	70	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2020	Rainbow Trout	150	9 in	report
March 1, 2020	Rainbow Trout	80	9 in	report
March 1, 2020	Rainbow Trout	80	9 in	report
March 1, 2020	Brown Trout	100	13 in	report
March 1, 2020	Brown Trout	150	9 in	report
November 1, 2019	Brown Trout	50	12.3 in	report
October 1, 2019	Brown Trout	100	12.1 in	report
May 1, 2019	Brown Trout	90	9 in	report
March 1, 2019	Rainbow Trout	100	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2019	Rainbow Trout	100	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2019	Rainbow Trout	200	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2019	Brown Trout	100	13.2 in	report
March 1, 2019	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2019	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
November 1, 2018	Brown Trout	50	11.5 in	report
October 1, 2018	Brown Trout	100	11.3 in	report
May 1, 2018	Brown Trout	90	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2018	Rainbow Trout	90	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2018	Rainbow Trout	90	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2018	Rainbow Trout	170	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2018	Brown Trout	100	13 in	report
March 1, 2018	Brown Trout	90	9.2 in	report
March 1, 2018	Brown Trout	90	9.2 in	report
November 1, 2017	Brown Trout	50	12 in	report
October 1, 2017	Brown Trout	100	11.8 in	report
May 1, 2017	Brown Trout	80	9.4 in	report
March 1, 2017	Rainbow Trout	200	9 in	report
March 1, 2017	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2017	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2017	Brown Trout	100	12.8 in	report
March 1, 2017	Brown Trout	80	9 in	report
March 1, 2017	Brown Trout	80	9 in	report
October 1, 2016	Brown Trout	50	12.2 in	report
October 1, 2016	Brown Trout	100	12 in	report
April 1, 2016	Brown Trout	90	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2016	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2016	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2016	Rainbow Trout	200	9 in	report
March 1, 2016	Brown Trout	100	13.4 in	report
March 1, 2016	Brown Trout	90	9 in	report
March 1, 2016	Brown Trout	90	9 in	report
November 1, 2015	Brown Trout	50	12 in	report
October 1, 2015	Brown Trout	100	11.9 in	report
April 1, 2015	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2015	Rainbow Trout	200	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2015	Rainbow Trout	100	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2015	Rainbow Trout	100	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2015	Brown Trout	100	13.5 in	report
March 1, 2015	Brown Trout	90	8.3 in	report
March 1, 2015	Brown Trout	90	8.3 in	report
November 1, 2014	Brown Trout	50	11.3 in	report
October 1, 2014	Brown Trout	100	11 in	report
April 1, 2014	Brown Trout	90	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2014	Rainbow Trout	80	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2014	Rainbow Trout	160	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2014	Rainbow Trout	80	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2014	Brown Trout	100	13.3 in	report
March 1, 2014	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2014	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
November 1, 2013	Brown Trout	50	11.7 in	report
October 1, 2013	Brown Trout	100	11.1 in	report
May 1, 2013	Brown Trout	70	9.1 in	report
March 1, 2013	Rainbow Trout	200	9 in	report
March 1, 2013	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2013	Rainbow Trout	100	9 in	report
March 1, 2013	Brown Trout	100	13.3 in	report
March 1, 2013	Brown Trout	70	8.2 in	report
March 1, 2013	Brown Trout	70	8.2 in	report
November 1, 2012	Brown Trout	50	11.6 in	report
October 1, 2012	Brown Trout	100	11.9 in	report
May 1, 2012	Brown Trout	90	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2012	Rainbow Trout	100	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2012	Rainbow Trout	200	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2012	Rainbow Trout	100	8.9 in	report
March 1, 2012	Brown Trout	100	13.4 in	report
March 1, 2012	Brown Trout	90	8.4 in	report
March 1, 2012	Brown Trout	90	8.4 in	report
November 1, 2011	Brown Trout	50	11.2 in	report
October 1, 2011	Brown Trout	100	11.3 in	report
May 1, 2011	Brown Trout	80	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2011	Rainbow Trout	200	8.1 in	report
March 1, 2011	Rainbow Trout	100	8.1 in	report
March 1, 2011	Rainbow Trout	100	8.1 in	report
March 1, 2011	Brown Trout	100	13.3 in	report
March 1, 2011	Brown Trout	80	8.8 in	report
March 1, 2011	Brown Trout	80	8.8 in	report

Show 93 more plants Show less

Species stocked here

Depth-by-season, top lures, and bait notes for each species stocked here are on its own species guide, linked above.