Fishing lakes in Erie County

Fishing lakes in Erie County, New York include 11 lakes. Brown Trout is stocked most often. The most recent plant was October 1, 2025 at Cattaraugus Creek. Buffalo is a town with at least 2 lakes on this list.

Fishing near Buffalo

Stocked with Rainbow Trout, Steelhead, and Brown Trout.

573 ft elevation
Rainbow TroutSteelhead 21 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
NOAA
597 ft elevation
Rainbow TroutBrown Trout 14 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2017 Open lake page →

Species stocked in Erie County

Species Plants Lakes
Brown Trout 361 9
Rainbow Trout 101 9
Steelhead 97 7
Brook Trout 4 1

Other lakes in Erie County

Darmon
599 ft elevation
Brown TroutSteelheadRainbow Trout 53 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Ken Winters, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
574 ft elevation
Brown TroutSteelheadRainbow Trout 199 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
André Carrotflower
583 ft elevation
SteelheadRainbow TroutBrown Trout 36 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
805 ft elevation
Brown TroutSteelhead 72 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Doug Kerr
572 ft elevation
Brown TroutSteelheadRainbow Trout 57 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Doug Kerr from Albany, NY, United States
565 ft elevation
Rainbow TroutBrown Trout 20 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →
690 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 47 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →
644 ft elevation
Steelhead 6 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2017 Open lake page →
564 ft elevation
Brown TroutBrook TroutRainbow Trout 38 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2024 Open lake page →

Other counties in New York