Fishing lakes in Cattaraugus County

Fishing lakes in Cattaraugus County, New York include 24 lakes. Brown Trout is stocked most often. The most recent plant was October 1, 2025 at Olean Creek.

24 locations shown. Click a pin for details.

Species stocked in Cattaraugus County

Species Plants Lakes
Brown Trout 516 19
Rainbow Trout 87 15
Brook Trout 56 6
Muskellunge 12 1
Walleye 10 2
Tiger Muskie 10 1

Lakes in Cattaraugus County

Bay State Brook
1,335 ft elevation
Brown Trout 10 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2020 Open lake page →
Birch Run
1,400 ft elevation
Brook TroutRainbow Trout 5 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2014 Open lake page →
Bone Run
1,331 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutRainbow Trout 28 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Connoisarauley Creek
1,020 ft elevation
Brook TroutRainbow TroutBrown Trout 12 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2021 Open lake page →
Elton Creek
1,277 ft elevation
Brown Trout 48 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Forks Creek
1,464 ft elevation
Brown Trout 27 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Great Valley Creek
1,370 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 47 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Haskell Creek
1,408 ft elevation
Brook TroutRainbow Trout 10 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2020 Open lake page →
Ischua Creek
1,441 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutRainbow Trout 127 plants
Last stocked June 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Lime Lake
1,632 ft elevation
WalleyeTiger Muskie 17 plants
Last stocked August 1, 2023 Open lake page →
Little Conewango Creek
1,265 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 43 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Mansfield Creek
1,275 ft elevation
Brown Trout 28 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
North Branch Sawmill Run
1,393 ft elevation
Brown Trout 10 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2020 Open lake page →
Oil Creek
1,445 ft elevation
Last stocked No record yet Open lake page →
Olean Creek
1,405 ft elevation
Brown TroutMuskellunge 22 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Oswayo Creek
1,415 ft elevation
Last stocked No record yet Open lake page →
Quaker Run
1,331 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 47 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Red House Brook
1,373 ft elevation
Brown TroutBrook TroutRainbow Trout 53 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Red House Lake
1,409 ft elevation
Brown TroutWalleyeRainbow Trout 67 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Rice Brook
1,389 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 10 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2020 Open lake page →
Mark Fischer
Science Lake
1,859 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 28 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Antepenultimate
South Branch Cattaraugus Creek
845 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 18 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
West Branch Conewango Creek
1,275 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 16 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2023 Open lake page →
Wrights Creek
1,438 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 18 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →

Other counties in New York