Fishing lakes in Chautauqua County

Fishing lakes in Chautauqua County, New York include 12 lakes. Muskellunge is stocked most often. The most recent plant was October 1, 2025 at Bear Lake.

12 locations shown. Click a pin for details.

Species stocked in Chautauqua County

Species Plants Lakes
Muskellunge 126 4
Brown Trout 109 6
Steelhead 59 4
Rainbow Trout 46 7
Walleye 38 4
Brook Trout 29 3

Lakes in Chautauqua County

Bear Lake
1,316 ft elevation
WalleyeMuskellunge 23 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Bear Lake Outlet
1,268 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 14 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2022 Open lake page →
Schetm
Canadaway Creek
578 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutSteelheadRainbow Trout 53 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Cassadaga Creek
1,236 ft elevation
Brown TroutWalleyeMuskellungeRainbow Trout 86 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Oceangod8 (talk) (Uploads)
Chautauqua Creek
573 ft elevation
SteelheadRainbow Trout 25 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Chautauqua Lake
1,306 ft elevation
WalleyeMuskellunge 75 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Clay Pond
1,245 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutRainbow Trout 27 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Findley Lake
1,418 ft elevation
WalleyeMuskellunge 20 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Michael Barera
Lake Erie
614 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow Trout 23 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2017 Open lake page →
Mill Creek
1,262 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutRainbow Trout 32 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2024 Open lake page →
Silver Creek
576 ft elevation
Steelhead 14 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Walnut Creek
571 ft elevation
Steelhead 15 plants
Last stocked March 1, 2025 Open lake page →

Other counties in New York