Fishing lakes in Herkimer County
Fishing lakes in Herkimer County, New York include 41 lakes. Brown Trout is stocked most often. The most recent plant was November 1, 2025 at Quiver Pond. Webb, Stillwater, Big Moose, Eagle Bay, and Ohio are towns with at least 2 lakes on this list.
41 locations shown. Click a pin for details.
Fishing near Webb
Stocked with Brook Trout, Brown Trout, and Splake, plus 3 more.
Fishing near Stillwater
Stocked with Brook Trout and Atlantic Salmon.
Fishing near Big Moose
Stocked with Brook Trout and Lake Trout.
James H Dunning
Fishing near Eagle Bay
Stocked with Brook Trout.
Fishing near Ohio
Stocked with Brook Trout, Splake, and Tiger Muskie.
Andy Arthur
Species stocked in Herkimer County
| Species | Plants | Lakes |
|---|---|---|
| Brown Trout | 353 | 7 |
| Brook Trout | 327 | 29 |
| Rainbow Trout | 59 | 3 |
| Tiger Muskie | 44 | 3 |
| Atlantic Salmon | 31 | 4 |
| Splake | 26 | 2 |
| Lake Trout | 19 | 2 |
Other lakes in Herkimer County
David T. Henrickson
Other counties in New York
- Albany County
- Allegany County
- Broome County
- Cattaraugus County
- Cayuga County
- Chautauqua County
- Chemung County
- Chenango County
- Clinton County
- Columbia County
- Cortland County
- Delaware County
- Dutchess County
- Erie County
- Essex County
- Franklin County
- Fulton County
- Genesee County
- Greene County
- Hamilton County
- Jefferson County
- Lewis County
- Livingston County
- Madison County
- Monroe County
- Montgomery County
- Nassau County
- New York County
- Niagara County
- Oneida County
- Onondaga County
- Ontario County
- Orange County
- Orleans County
- Oswego County
- Otsego County
- Putnam County
- Rensselaer County
- Rockland County
- Saratoga County
- Schenectady County
- Schoharie County
- Schuyler County
- Seneca County
- St. Lawrence County
- Steuben County
- Suffolk County
- Sullivan County
- Tioga County
- Tompkins County
- Ulster County
- Warren County
- Washington County
- Wayne County
- Westchester County
- Wyoming County
- Yates County