Fishing lakes in Cayuga County
16 lakes on record in Cayuga County, New York. Brown Trout is stocked most often. The most recent plant was in November 2025 at Cayuga Lake. Fair Haven has at least 2 lakes on this list as its nearest town.
- Most recent plant
- November 2025
- Cayuga Lake
- Lakes
- 16
- Plants
- 448
- Species stocked
- 10
Lakes in Cayuga County
16 locations shown. Tap a pin for details. · Open this area in Google Maps
Fishing near Fair Haven
Stocked with Steelhead, Chinook Salmon, and Brown Trout.
Shore access at 1 lake. A boat ramp at 2 lakes.
| Photo | Lake | Plants | Last stocked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lake Ontario | 15 plants | May 2025 | |
| Little Sodus Bay | 19 plants | March 2020 | |
| Sterling Creek | 18 plants | March 2020 | |
| Sterling Valley Creek | 10 plants | March 2020 |
Other lakes in Cayuga County
Species stocked in Cayuga County
| Species | Plants | Lakes |
|---|---|---|
| Brown Trout | 145 | 5 |
| Atlantic Salmon | 64 | 3 |
| Rainbow Trout | 62 | 4 |
| Lake Trout | 41 | 2 |
| Tiger Muskie | 37 | 3 |
| Steelhead | 30 | 3 |
| Brook Trout | 30 | 2 |
| Chinook Salmon | 17 | 2 |
Other counties in New York
Albany CountyAllegany CountyBroome CountyCattaraugus CountyChautauqua CountyChemung CountyChenango CountyClinton CountyColumbia CountyCortland CountyDelaware CountyDutchess CountyErie CountyEssex CountyFranklin CountyFulton CountyGenesee CountyGreene CountyHamilton CountyHerkimer CountyJefferson CountyLewis CountyLivingston CountyMadison CountyMonroe CountyMontgomery CountyNassau CountyNew York CountyNiagara CountyOneida CountyOnondaga CountyOntario CountyOrange CountyOrleans CountyOswego CountyOtsego CountyPutnam CountyRensselaer CountyRockland CountySaratoga CountySchenectady CountySchoharie CountySchuyler CountySeneca CountySt. Lawrence CountySteuben CountySuffolk CountySullivan CountyTioga CountyTompkins CountyUlster CountyWarren CountyWashington CountyWayne CountyWestchester CountyWyoming CountyYates County
Common questions
Which lakes are in Cayuga County?
16 lakes in Cayuga County, New York.
What fish are stocked most in Cayuga County?
Brown Trout is stocked most often.
Which lake was stocked most recently?
The most recent plant was in November 2025 at Cayuga Lake.