Fishing lakes in Otsego County

Fishing lakes in Otsego County, New York include 12 lakes. Brown Trout is stocked most often. The most recent plant was October 1, 2025 at Allen Lake.

12 locations shown. Click a pin for details.

Species stocked in Otsego County

Species Plants Lakes
Brown Trout 250 11
Rainbow Trout 72 3
Brook Trout 48 3
Walleye 22 1
Lake Trout 16 1
Tiger Muskie 10 1
Atlantic Salmon 2 1

Lakes in Otsego County

420Traveler, via Wikimedia Commons
Allen Lake
1,642 ft elevation
Brook TroutBrown TroutRainbow Trout 82 plants
Last stocked October 1, 2025 Open lake page →
420Traveler, via Wikimedia Commons
Arnold Lake
1,777 ft elevation
Brown TroutRainbow TroutBrook Trout 45 plants
Last stocked June 1, 2025 Open lake page →
420Traveler
Butternut Creek
1,006 ft elevation
Brown Trout 9 plants
Last stocked May 1, 2011 Open lake page →
Canadarago Lake
1,280 ft elevation
WalleyeTiger Muskie 32 plants
Last stocked July 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Elk Creek
1,218 ft elevation
Brown Trout 34 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Gilbert Lake
1,516 ft elevation
Rainbow TroutBrown TroutBrook Trout 46 plants
Last stocked June 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Oaks Creek
1,174 ft elevation
Brown Trout 19 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2020 Open lake page →
420Traveler
Otego Creek
1,050 ft elevation
Brown Trout 44 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Otsdawa Creek
1,036 ft elevation
Brown Trout 16 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2023 Open lake page →
George Roger Gilbert
Otsego Lake
1,195 ft elevation
Brown TroutLake TroutAtlantic Salmon 21 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Schenevus Creek
1,134 ft elevation
Brown Trout 49 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →
Unadilla River
969 ft elevation
Brown Trout 23 plants
Last stocked April 1, 2025 Open lake page →

Other counties in New York